11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea.
There’s something magical about afternoon tea. Don’t you think so too? Because I love going somewhere special and even making afternoon tea, whenever we get chance.
It is one of my favourite things to do, especially in spring or summer when the weather is warming up.
Maybe it’s the bite-sized elegance, maybe it’s the excuse to eat multiple sandwiches and mini cakes or maybe it’s just the joy of carbs with zero guilt because I have planned it.
Either way, if you want to host a tea that people actually remember (and secretly envy), these 11 sandwich recipes are your golden ticket.
Disclosure: Some images in this post may also be created or enhanced using AI. This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through these links.
Photos in todays post inspired by a trip to Peter Pan Afternoon Tea in The Shard and Alice in Wonderland.
Update Post. Note from the editor: This post content has been updated and modernised in October 2026 after it was first published in April 2026.
Hello friends, so how are you today? Happy Sunday.
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea:
On the blog today, I am sharing;
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea.
Afternoon tea is one of life’s simplest luxuries, where you serve delicate sandwiches, a warm drink, and a moment to slow down.
These eleven sandwich ideas bring a touch of elegance to any table, each offering a balance of flavour, texture, and indulgence.
Table Of Contents:
- Firstly, Egg Mayo & Cress.
- Secondly, Coronation Chicken.
- Thirdly, Ham And English Mustard.
- Fourthly, Chocolate & Strawberry.
- Fifth, Classic Cucumber & Cream Cheese.
- Sixth, Jam Sandwiches.
- Seventh, Smoked Salmon & Dill.
- Eight, Chicken, Pesto & Mozzarella.
- Ninth, Roast Beef & Horseradish.
- Tenth, Brie, Apple & Honey.
- Eleventh, Avocado And Tomato.
Egg Mayo & Cress:
Firstly, Egg Mayo & Cress.
Simple, nostalgic, and ridiculously good. Egg Mayonnaise Creamy Sandwich. Egg Mayonnaise, creamy chopped egg with mayo.
Cooked eggs, cooled and mashed up with mayonnaise and cress. Indeed, great for afternoon tea. Also, one of my favourites!! Egg Mayo & Cress is a timeless classic. Creamy egg mayonnaise paired with peppery cress creates a soft yet slightly sharp bite. Also, my favourite.
Usual Ingredients:
- Boiled eggs
- Mayonnaise
- Mustard (optional)
- Fresh cress
- White or wholemeal bread
Making a tasty sandwich begins with cracking open the hard-boiled eggs. A creamy and flavourful base is produced by gently crushing the eggs and adding precisely the appropriate amount of mayonnaise.
The flavour can be enhanced with a hint of mustard, which gives it a tangy bite.
In the meantime, a dash of salt and pepper improves the seasoned profile and guarantees a flavour that is well-balanced.
This delicious egg combination offers a delightful crunch when spread over freshly toasted bread but perfect on bread for afternoon tea.
Lastly, adding cress or even juicy tomato slices and crisp lettuce leaves to the sandwich’s top adds a refreshing touch while also improving its texture.
In conclusion, making a hard-boiled egg sandwich entails a number of meticulously planned stages that culminate in a delightful and delectable culinary experience.
Why not try these tea sandwiches. Creamy, perfectly seasoned egg mayonnaise, with a hint of Dijon mustard in the homemade mayonnaise: meets the refreshing peppery bite of tender watercress leaves.
Nestled between slices of freshly baked, crustless white bread, each bite offers a harmonious blend of creaminess and crunch.
These dainty delights are a quintessential addition to your afternoon tea, delivering a timeless taste of sophistication and comfort in every bite.
Coronation Chicken:
Secondly, Coronation Chicken.
Coronation Chicken, curried mayo chicken with a hint of sweetness. A British classic with a royal twist.
Coronation Chicken adds a hint of sweetness and spice, blending curried mayonnaise with tender chicken for a richly satisfying filling.
Yes, please!! Created for the Queen’s coronation in 1953, what street party would be complete without Coronation Chicken? So tasty.
Also, a recipe idea:
Ingredients:
- Cooked chicken (shredded)
- Mayonnaise
- Curry powder
- Mango chutney
- Raisins
Why it works: Sweet, savoury, and just a little unexpected.
Thirdly, Ham And English Mustard.
Bold, punchy, and impossible to ignore. Also, so tasty.
Ingredients:
- Sliced ham
- Butter
- English mustard
- White bread
The Ham and English Mustard delivers a bold contrast, salty ham with the fiery kick of mustard.
Fourthly, Chocolate & Strawberry (Yes, Really).
Because tea sandwiches don’t have to be savoury. So much fun too.
Ingredients:
- Soft brioche
- Chocolate spread
- Fresh strawberries
Chocolate & Strawberry feels almost dessert-like, combining juicy fruit with smooth chocolate for a treat that melts in your mouth.
Also, Why Not Try A Strawberry Sandwich Recipe?
Strawberry Sandwich. Why not try something a little different!? Of course strawberries are so full of flavour.
So much fun and great for afternoon tea. Because who does not love afternoon tea?
While they may look like white bread spread with butter and filled with salad they are actually made with thinly sliced white chocolate cake.
Or Strawberry And Cream Cheese, lightly sweet. Or Strawberry And Butter, simple and delicate.
Classic Cucumber & Cream Cheese:
Fifth, Classic Cucumber & Cream Cheese.
Classic Cucumber & Cream Cheese is the essence of afternoon tea, cool, crisp cucumber layered with silky cream cheese.
The timeless icon. Never skip it.
Ingredients:
- Soft white bread
- Cream cheese
- Thinly sliced cucumber
- Salt, pepper
Pro tip: Lightly salt cucumbers and pat dry to avoid soggy sandwiches.
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea:
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea.
Sixth, Jam Sandwiches.
Jam Sandwiches may be simple, but their sweetness and nostalgia make them irresistible. Discover the perfect balance of fruity sweetness in this homemade jam recipe, crafted with love and care.
Seventh, Smoked Salmon & Dill.
Effortlessly elegant. Tastes like money.
Smoked Salmon & Dill brings a refined, slightly smoky flavour lifted by fresh herbs.
Fancy Making Some Easy Salmon Sandwiches? Perfect For Afternoon Tea.
Ingredients:
- Brown bread
- Smoked salmon
- Cream cheese
- Fresh dill
- Lemon zest
Chicken, Pesto & Mozzarella:
Eight, Chicken, Pesto & Mozzarella.
Italian-inspired indulgence.
Chicken, Pesto & Mozzarella offers a Mediterranean twist, with fragrant pesto and creamy cheese enhancing tender chicken.
Ingredients:
- Cooked chicken
- Pesto
- Mozzarella
- Ciabatta or soft rolls
Chicken Salad Ciabatta With Sweet Pickles & Mayonnaise:
Or Chicken Salad Ciabatta With Sweet Pickles & Mayonnaise.
It’s a symphony of flavours that dances on your palate with every bite. The savoury chicken mingling with the tangy sweetness of pickles, and the smoothness of mayo embracing every corner of your mouth.
It’s a culinary adventure you won’t soon forget!
So, whether you’re picnicking in the park or simply craving a satisfying lunch, indulge in the delicious harmony of Chicken Salad Ciabatta with Sweet Pickles & Mayonnaise.
Let your taste buds thank you later!
Roast Beef & Horseradish:
Ninth, Roast Beef & Horseradish.
For when your tea party needs a bit of attitude.
Roast Beef & Horseradish is robust and satisfying, with the horseradish adding a gentle heat. So tasty.
Ingredients:
- Roast beef slices
- Horseradish sauce
- Rocket
- Wholegrain bread
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea:
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea.
Tenth, Brie, Apple & Honey.
Sweet meets creamy meets crunchy.
Brie, Apple & Honey balances creamy, crisp, and sweet elements into one luxurious bite. So good.
Ingredients:
- Brie cheese
- Thin apple slices
- Honey drizzle
- Walnut bread
Eleventh, Avocado And Tomato.
Fresh, modern, and Instagram-ready.
Avocado and Tomato provides a fresh, modern option, combining creamy avocado with juicy tomatoes.
Ingredients:
- Ripe avocado
- Cherry tomatoes
- Lemon juice
- Salt & chili flakes
Together, these sandwiches transform any afternoon tea into something truly special, refined, comforting, and just a little addictive. So tasty.
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea:
11 Afternoon Tea Sandwich Recipes That Will Make You Feel Fancy And Slightly Addicted To Afternoon Tea.
Claire Justine Oxox- Over 50s Lifestyle Blog. You can also read more about me here: Over 50s Lifestyle Blog.
Thank you so much for stopping by. Finally, lovelies; I also hope you like this post?
If so, why not follow along so you never miss a post? So remember you can also share your thoughts here too in the comments below.
Did You Also See: 11 Alice In Wonderland Tea Party Recipes Ideas.
Love afternoon tea? Love a classic story? As I know I do, ever since I was a little girl.
If you do too, follow me down the rabbit hole for a wonderfully whimsical Alice In Wonderland afternoon tea party ideas. Inspired by Lewis Carroll.
Fill your imagination, with pretty cakes, colourful treats, sandwiches and plenty of tea! Welcome to Wonderland!
If you’re planning an Alice in Wonderland themed tea party, birthday party, afternoon tea or simply fancy an excuse to make your next get-together a little more magical.
I’ve got some delicious ideas that I’ve made up in my head and can not wait to have time to try them. Do you want to try them out with me?
Fancy taking a little read? This post is an unofficial independent created afternoon tea recipe ideas post. For me and you to try out.
To make an afternoon tea inspired by Lewis Carroll’s original book Alice’s Adventures In Wonderland.
11 Alice In Wonderland Tea Party Recipes Ideas.
Peter Pan Afternoon Tea At The Shard | A Magical London Adventure:
You Might Like: Peter Pan Afternoon Tea At The Shard | A Magical London Adventure.
If you’re a dreamer like me (and still believe in fairies), then you’re going to love this one! Because I did.
On Monday, we had the most magical afternoon tea, way up high above London. 32 floors to be precise, at the Peter Pan Afternoon Tea at The Shard!
Honestly, it felt like stepping straight into Neverland itself.
Think twinkling city views, right next to the window, tiny golden pastries, and just enough pixie dust to make your heart flutter.
Don’t even get me started on the sweet delights! So good.
They are delivered on an imitated pirate ship, and a waitress poured some liquid into the heart of the ship to ignite the dry ice, creating a billowing, theatrical “smoky fog” impression at your table.
That was magical.
Dreams do come true, if only we wish hard enough.
Also, Read Here: Peter Pan Afternoon Tea At The Shard | A Magical London Adventure.
You Might Also Like The Latest From The Blog. Also, find me on: Web | Twitter | Facebook.
How To Also Make Them Look Actually Fancy:
How to Make Them Look Actually Fancy:
- Firstly, trim crusts (this is non-negotiable in tea culture).
- Secondly, cut into fingers, triangles, or delicate squares.
- Thirdly, use a mix of breads for visual variety.
- Fourthly, stack neatly on a tiered stand for maximum effect.
What Tea To Serve?
- English Breakfast
- Earl Grey
- Green tea
- Herbal blends (like chamomile or peppermint).
Also, provide milk, lemon, and sugar so guests can customise their cup.
For me, afternoon tea isn’t just about food, it’s about creating a moment.
These sandwiches are small, but they carry big energy.
So whether you’re hosting friends, impressing guests, or just treating yourself on a random Tuesday, these recipes guarantee one thing: You’ll never look at a basic sandwich the same way again.
So tasty, don’t you think?
Afternoon Tea Inspired Pinterest Board:
Also, Visit My Afternoon Tea Inspired Recipes Pinterest Board:
Step up your tea time with these irresistible afternoon tea sandwich recipes.
From classic cucumber & cream cheese to indulgent smoked salmon, coronation chicken, and even sweet chocolate & strawberry bites, this board is your go-to for elegant, bite-sized inspiration.
Also, perfect for brunches, garden parties, bridal showers, or a cosy afternoon treat at home.
Discover simple yet sophisticated sandwich ideas, styling tips, and flavour combinations that turn every tea moment into something special.
So, save now for your next tea party. Afternoon Tea. Tea Party Ideas. Finger Sandwiches. Brunch Inspo.
Also, Visit Here: Afternoon Tea Inspired Pinterest Board.
So what do you think? Do you also love afternoon tea? Because I do.